News Alert
Oakland Man Arrested on Suspicion of Possessing…

Dublin To Grab Fire Dept Offices From San Leandro?

Their mayor says offices now in San Leandro will move to the 'burbs, potentially costing our city some bucks -- and pushing our mayor's nose out of joint.


It's not bad enough that San Leandro could lose $100,000 if the Alameda County Fire Department finalizes a plan to move its administrative offices from a corner of our City Hall to an entire building in Dublin.

It was how San Leandro Mayor Stephen Cassidy learned of the pending move that irks him.

In a March 22nd video blog aired on Dublin Patch (copy attached), that city's mayor, Tim Sbranti, revealed that Dublin was prepping two city-owned buildings to accommodate county fire department functions that had resided in or near San Leandro for more than 15 years.

That was news to Cassidy, whose office is just steps away from where Alameda County Fire Chief Seldon Gilbert works on the second floor of San Leandro City Hall.

"I don't like being caught by surprise," Cassidy growled.

San Leandro Patch caught up with Chief Gilbert Thursday, who said no slight was intended.

It is important to note that no fire station closures or shifts are involved.

But there is some taxpayer money at stake, along with municipal pride over which town gets to headquarter the fast-growing empire that is the Alameda County Fire Department.

Here's how Dublin made a bold bid to capture the flag.

The History

The story begins in the mid-1990s, shortly after the county fire department first came together. Around this time San Leandro became the first city to give up its independent fire fighting unit and entrust that mission to the county.

At roughly the same time, about 1996, San Leandro expanded City Hall. And in the way of the world, its new partner, Alameda County Fire, sublet a chunk of that new office space.

The fire department has been there ever since. It now has about 15 employees in 3,600 square feet of space that costs about $52,000 a year.

So that money would be lost to the city if the move occurs. In addition, San Leandro would have to contribute a like amount toward the rent of the new offices in Dublin, adding up to about $100,000 loss for the home team.

But as Gilbert explained Thursday, the fire department has outgrown its digs. In the last five years alone it has gone from 220 personnel to about 440 firefighters and emergency medical service providers.

In addition to San Leandro, it now serves Union City, Newark, Dublin and, soon, Emeryville. It also has contracts with Lawrence Livermore and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratories.

Gilbert said the deparment has been looking for more space for years and has gone through several competitive bids with private sector rental agents -- some in San Leandro -- but all had come to naught.

Recently, he said, Dublin offered to move the fire department's administrative offices into one building about four times the size of its space in San Leandro -- at $211,000 a year or roughly four times the rent.

Dublin also offered to provide a second site for a maintenance facility -- the department now does that work at Fire Station 24 on 164th Street in Ashland.

The key, Gilbert said, was that Dublin owned both sites. Deals between two government agencies can be done quickly and without competitive bidding.

All that remains is to work out the details and get the deal approved.

"It could come before the (Board of) Supervisors in the May or June time frame," Gilbert said.

Does 680 Rule While 880 Drools?

Cassidy said the larger issue is where the department sees its future. He thinks it's on this side of the hills, where the county could potentially take over Oakland's fire protection and create a more compact service area.

So the headquarters should be where the service area is concentrated.

He is also not persuaded the deal makes economic sense.

"It was not done through a competitive bid," Cassidy said.

Gilbert laid out his financial rationale for the move in a March 26 letter to San Leandro City Manager Chris Zapata, a copy of which is attached in PDF form.

Bottom line, Gilbert said, is that the department needs more room than San Leandro can provide.

Even a casual inspection suggests that the current maintainence location is cramped. Equipment is serviced on one side of an active fire station that runs trucks out of the other side. Parts are stored in cargo containers out back. Those big honking tires on fire trucks have to be balanced and handled inside one of these steel rectangles.

But according to Gilbert's plan, it would take a $3.5 million investment to get the new yard in Dublin running.

He said the department has a "business model" to expand the repair work it is already doing for other departments -- and could do more of if it had the space -- and make money for the county.

As for quadrupling its office space at quadruple the cost, Gilbert said the department has administrative functions scattered hither and yon. Gathering them all in one place would require fewer copiers and consolidate support staff.

Why one can almost feel the synergy -- and smell the freshly-mowed suburban grass.

(Sign up to get San Leandro Patch delivered by email.)



Paul Vargas April 06, 2012 at 03:51 PM
Government agency cannibalism. Taxpayer money going from one agency to another under the guise of "making the county a profit"???? Preposterous. It's time to pull out from these jokers, all the Alameda County Fire Dept. is doing is hiring non needed personell in order to bloat their own opinion of self worth. Then they'll be knocking on doors wanting taxes raised to pay for their bloated salaries and pensions.
Thomas Clarke April 06, 2012 at 04:22 PM
This is really all a reaction by the union to Cassidy. Stephen is now beginning to feel the love that his outsider anti-union attitude brings. Of course it did not hurt any that the Mayor waited forever to appoint a city manager. With all the open space in San Leandro it is hard to imagine that there was a simple solution in town for less money. If there is not a simple solution then bye bye ACFD.
Mike April 06, 2012 at 04:28 PM
If the mayor ever spent any time in city hall he might have gotten an inkling of this but since m-f he is in San Francisco when folks are working in city hall he gets blindsided.
Leah Hall April 06, 2012 at 04:36 PM
Doesn't the Alameda Fire Department and the Dublin Mayor's office have telephones? Better yet, a pair of legs for stepping out of the office and knocking on the San Leandro mayor's office next door? Stickies, perhaps? Dry erase markers? Bongo drums for tapping out a message in Morse code? ;-)
Paul Vargas April 06, 2012 at 04:45 PM
Good bye and good riddance. Cut the contract with them. They're wasting money. Why do they need to balance their own tires? That can by done privately. Are the firemen also doing the balancing of the tires? Patch needs to be more inclusive of what is going on.
Fran April 06, 2012 at 04:52 PM
So what. They found better suited digs in Dublin. The PDF says it was put out to bid. Are we crying over a measly 100k? Or the bragging rights?
Paul Vargas April 06, 2012 at 10:24 PM
San Carlos was looking into having a private company do their fire department. That's something that seriously needs to be done.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something