.
Feedback

Seismic Expert Talks About Recent Quakes

Albany resident and seismic expert Dr. Robert Uhrhammer says last week’s Berkeley-centric Hayward Fault earthquakes are not a reliable portent of the future.

Every time there’s an earthquake, let alone , seismic legends and lore fly. This means the Big One will hit soon. This means the Big One won’t hit soon. Highly unusual. No biggie – enjoy the ride. 

Help us put this string of shakers in perspective, people asked last week. 

We phoned retired UC Berkeley seismologist  who happens to live in Albany, to help put last week’s eight local quakes in context. Uhrhammer, a seismic researcher and instrumentalist, still works in Cal’s Seismology Lab.

How many earthquakes were recorded in the Berkeley area last week?

There have been 10 events since Oct. 20, all on the Hayward Fault. The first quake, , occurred at 2:41 p.m., epicentered just southeast of the UC campus between the Clark Kerr campus and the Claremont Hotel. It had a depth of eight kilometers, or 5 miles.  

The . All of these events occurred in a 2.6-kilometer radius of the first quake -- Berkeley’s own cluster. 

How do you distinguish aftershocks? 

Basically, the timing. In California, two thirds of the time, when we look at a grouping of earthquakes, the biggest is the first. About one third of the time, we see one or more earthquakes preceding the main one, those are foreshocks. 

Where are foreshocks most common? 

In volcanic regions, such as along the Pacific Rim

When do people start feeling quakes?

At a threshold of magnitude 2. That’s when people start reporting them. 

Was the recent Hayward Fault quake sequence rare? 

No. Since 1970, there have been about 1,200 earthquakes in a 10-kilometer radius of . Most of them are quite small; much smaller than what people would feel.

If you look at the seismic patterns, the cluster we’ve had in the past week doesn’t look anomalous or unusual when compared to other clusters that occur along the Hayward Fault.

The Hayward Fault behaves quite differently than other fault systems in the Bay Area. On the Hayward, earthquakes all occur in clusters or pockets, not along a continuum, which is more common. These little patches cover only 2 to 5 percent of the whole Fault. 

Locally, there are pockets in Berkeley, Oakland, El Cerrito, Richmond and Pinole. They tend to occur where the Fault has bends or steps on it. The Fault isn’t a nice straight line. 

Does the recent sequence give a read on the future?

Not really. Whenever there is a cluster of little earthquakes like this on this section of Hayward Fault, statistically and mathematically the probability of getting a big earthquake within a few days increases a little, by about 1 to 2 percent. More probable minutes to hours after the first shock. 

Every day that passes, this drops off. The most likely scenario is that a big quake would occur soon, within a few days of the biggest quake. (This is on the rare foreshock occasion.)

What about further in the future - The Big One?

I can never say that we’re due; I can only say what the probability is. Using our best evidence at this time, in the next 30 years, there’s a 65 percent chance that we’ll get a magnitude-6.7 or larger on one or more of the seven Bay Area fault systems capable of producing quakes of this size. 

If we go specifically to the Hayward, there’s a 28 percent chance of getting a magnitude-6.7 or larger in the next 30 years. This is the greatest “hazard probability” of all the seven fault systems. 

The Hayward also has a great risk probability. There are 3.5 million people living in the Hayward fault zone, extending out 15 miles. 

Every year, there’s approximately a 1 percent chance of a magnitude-7 earthquake or greater occurring along this section of the Hayward Fault. That means a 99 percent chance it won’t. 

I’ve heard that small quakes relieve stress, lessening the chance of future major earthquakes? 

That is wrong. There just aren’t enough small quakes to significantly impact the “strain release,” or to mitigate the possibility of a large earthquake occurring. 

The Hayward Fault zone is accumulating what’s called elastic strain energy at the rate of about four-tenths of an inch a year. This is from the collision of the Pacific Plate and the North American Plate. The Farallon Islands are moving northwest about two inches a year. Those two inches are distorting the earth’s crust or creating strain energy. The crust will break where the strain is the weakest, namely the preexisting fault zones.

It’s like pulling a rubber sheet tighter and tighter. As time goes on, you’re storing more and more strained energy. 

Earthquakes do release this energy, but only very slightly. The largest, and usually the first quake in a sequence, releases the most energy. Smaller aftershocks release much less as they drop in magnitude. (For every magnitude increase in a quake, the strain energy release goes up by a factor of 32.)

In fact, if a series of small quakes occurs in a stress pocket (asperity) on a fault, it can redistribute the pressure, increasing the chance of a larger quake.

You live near the Hayward Fault. Do you fear quakes?

I live on the west side of Albany Hill, which is pretty solid ground. If you have a house that’s retrofitted to modern codes, and you’re sitting on fairly firm material, the severity of the ground shaking is less than if you’re sitting on loose fill like bay muds. 

Whereever you live, always be aware of the potential of a large earthquake to occur and . 

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from San Leandro Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
california girl May 18, 2013 at 08:05 pm
I loved the green tea!
anthony May 17, 2013 at 01:01 pm
go nuts, or one of each... for later of course. would go scone myself, old habits die hard.
Leah Hall May 19, 2013 at 01:59 pm
Young man! The stormtroopers get into the act.... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MuJXaVrvpXE
Justin Agrella May 19, 2013 at 09:43 am
http://youtu.be/78LAgl90UyM
Leah Hall May 16, 2013 at 05:04 pm
Youth development, healthy living & social responsibility... ...in San Leandro! For the firstRead More time ever! Thanks to everyone who brought the YMCA "Move-A-Thon" to San Leandro and all the families that participated! -Leah Hall SL Human Services Commissioner & Volunteer YMCA Youth & Government advisor (for our San Leandro delegation comprised of San Leandro high school students)
Scott Terry May 23, 2013 at 08:38 pm
Hi Christa...I'm the guy in the story that Anthony posted the link for, and I keep bees in SanRead More Leandro. There are several beekeepers in town, and bees will fly up to 3 miles to collect pollen and nectar, but I don't know if there are any beekeepers near you. If the city council approves the keeping of bees in city limits, then it's likely that someone will get bees closer to you, but you don't need to have a hive right on your property.
anthony May 18, 2013 at 04:31 pm
remembered reading this here, maybe ther's a forward in thereRead More somewhere...http://sanleandro.patch.com/groups/politics-and-elections/p/local-hungry-families-helped-by-urban-farmer. Don't hold me to this one, but I thought Tim at Zocalo Coffee was a keeper.
Richard Mellor May 15, 2013 at 06:38 pm
I have a friend who has just had a hive put in her garden If you would like me to put u in touchRead More with her contact me at aactivist@igc.org
RHG May 17, 2013 at 03:46 pm
First let me say sorry for the loss of one of your family. Ive been keeping my eyes pealed incase IRead More see him. But I'd recomend since he is going blind, it might be easyer for someone to catch him if we knew his name. Just a thought. Hope for his safe return.
Carol Parker May 14, 2013 at 08:45 pm
I'm happy to report Buster found a forever home on Mother's Day. There are other bassets availableRead More for adoption on Golden Gate Basset Rescue's website, however. Adoptable dogs will be on hand June 9 from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. at Pet Food Express on Blanding Avenue (in the shopping center of Nob Hill Foods) in Alameda. Come down and see some hounds up close and personal.
Stefanie Pruegel January 29, 2013 at 05:11 pm
I would speculate that more durable, reusable bags still score a lot better than disposables, evenRead More if a small fraction of those are "dual use" as in the cases you point out (dog poop, trash can liner). BTW, for those concerned about a dwindling supply of free poop bags as a result of the ban, here are still plenty of plastic bags available for that purpose e.g. those that people's newspaper comes in. The bottom line is that most people would agree that reusable bags are the better solution than to continue choking our waterways with disposable plastic bags.
David January 21, 2013 at 10:12 pm
There are plenty of competing studies that disagree. I perused that, and one huge faulty assumptionRead More that they have is that "single use" means single use when as we see above, people use them for dogs, garbage etc.
Stefanie Pruegel January 21, 2013 at 09:47 pm
Funny you should bring up cost/benefit analysis of disposable plastic bags vs reusable bags, David.Read More This is exactly what was done in 2010 by a coalition of several California cities and organizations, to help communities in the state gauge the impact of any ordinance they consider passing in regards to disposable bags. The upshot is that reusable bags (particularly non-woven plastic reusable bags) have significantly lower environmental impacts on a per-use basis than single-use plastic bags. Find the full study here: http://bit.ly/VWdEn9
Sarah Nash May 10, 2013 at 02:18 pm
Just had a chance to read this story. Loved it! While I believe that conscientious students wouldRead More try their best at the test, as I did when I took state aptitude tests in school, I can hardly imagine staying up nights worrying about it! There is nothing at stake except perhaps personal satisfaction so the test itself shouldn't impose stress. A high-strung parent, on the other hand, might.
David April 27, 2013 at 03:09 pm
Oh come on, Rob. You talk about me cherry picking stuff? 10/10? Sure. And as I've shown you canRead More pull out Maxwell Park, North Oakland, parts of SF (Glen Park, for example), parts of El Cerrito and other locations to show that API scores aren't well-correlated with property values. Again, why do homes sell for the same $/sq foot in Maxwell Park as Estudillo Estates? San Lorenzo's API is about the same or better than most of SLUSD. Property values there are lower. The clearest example of what effect API scores have on property values was mentioned below, about a 10% difference depending on which side of the tracks, er, 580 you live on in Castro Valley. 10%? whoopdedo, that kind of variation is washed out when you factor in commute times, crime, amenities, etc. In fact, API scores are likely to continue to shrink as a factor in RE values as more and more parents flee the public schools, no matter what the API (witness SLUSD, the 30% drop in OUSD enrollment in just the past decade, etc). In another generation, we'll be accused by our children of child abuse by having sent them to public schools.
Rob Rich April 27, 2013 at 12:38 pm
If you accept the premise that API scores are poorly correlated with real estate vualues, then is itRead More coincidental that the top school districts are in areas with high real estate values? http://www.greatschools.org/find-a-school/7046-ten-california-school-districts-highest-test-scores-2012.gs. In the old days, 10 for 10 was considered pretty good correlation.